Rob Johnson from The Roanoke Times printed an article about nonbelievers at Christmas time. I was interviewed but none of my quotes were used. I think I was far younger, happier and knew much more about the origins of the holiday than they wanted their portrait of Atheists to be.
And then they found one of the most conservative lunatic pastors in the entire area to give a quote about Atheists. A quote that made just about as much sense as unicorn testicles in a blender with toast.
It’s not the best article in the world, but it’s a start.
Nonbelievers go through the motions
The religious and consumer nature of the holidays can be irksome for atheists, though some concessions are made in the spirit of the season.
By Rob Johnson
981-3234
Photos by Sam Dean | The Roanoke Times
[photo missing]
Robert Boyd enjoys hearing from friends who send Christmas cards. Most know him well enough not to send greetings with religious themes.
[photo missing]
Jerry Schleifer, an 82-year-old atheist, considers which gift cards to buy at a Roanoke-area Kroger grocery store. His children and grandchildren expect presents around the holidays, so he buys the gift cards without acknowledging that they’re Christmas gifts.
Jerry Schleifer wishes the Grinch would steal Christmas and never bring it back. “The whole thing is a farce,” he said.
The holiday season is an annual reminder to the Southwest Roanoke County grandfather that he is part of a distinct minority of unabashed nonbelievers in this country.
According to a poll earlier this year by the Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life, one in 20 Americans is an avowed atheist. That proportion is likely even smaller in Bible Belt areas such as Southwest Virginia.
For such people, the December holidays can be a tortuous gauntlet. Schleifer, 82, tries to avoid shopping, even for personal necessities. “I buy sweaters in the summer,” he said.
Still, his children and grandchildren expect presents, so he goes to Kroger to purchase gift cards for various chain stores — without acknowledging that they’re Christmas gifts. “They’re just presents,” he insisted.
Atheists often keep to themselves at this “Most Wonderful Time of the Year.” Robert Boyd, a retired college science professor who lives in Daleville, said that during the Christmas holidays, he and his wife, also an atheist, “just stay home.” They put up a small Christmas tree. “It’s just a decoration, that’s all,” he said.
While such remarks dismay Christians, Schleifer and Boyd are part of an atheist genre far less activist than the likes of Madalyn Murray O’Hair, the atheist whose lawsuit led to a Supreme Court ruling that ended the practice of daily prayer in public schools. In 1964, Life magazine called her “the most hated woman in America.”
In sharp contrast, Scott Mange, a medical physicist in Salem, just wants to get through the celebration of Jesus’ birthday quietly and without his second-grade daughter and kindergarten son being exposed to the Bible’s account of drama in Bethlehem. “We don’t tell our children the story of baby Jesus. We’ve also told them the truth about Santa Claus,” Mange said.
Raised in a Catholic home, Mange grew away from the church in his late teens when “I decided that it was all made-up stuff.”
Still, he doesn’t want to offend the faithful, and that caused some awkward moments in early December when a co-worker at his office made ceramic angels as Christmas tree ornaments for her colleagues. But she didn’t give one to Mange, having heard that he is an atheist. “She avoided me,” he said.
Yet after seeing one of the angels on a co-worker’s desk, Mange said, he took a liking to the little statuette and asked the associate if she had one left.
“The thing that really got me was that she was willing to consider how a nonbeliever felt. That was nice,” said Mange, 43.
He took the angel home, where the family has a Christmas tree, but he hasn’t placed the figure among the other decorations. That would violate his policy against religious decorations on their tree.
Still, “I’d kind of like to put it on the tree” because of the warm spirit in which the angel was given, he said.
While conflicted, he said he won’t give in to sentimentality that tacitly endorses religion. “I’ve heard it said that the saddest person in the world is the atheist who wants to say thanks to God for something like a sunset, but he can’t because he knows no one is listening.”
That’s sort of how Mange feels about Christmas, he said: “I can’t fool myself.”
The Rev. Myron Atkinson of Penn Forest Worship Center has been thinking about atheists lately. He recently put the following anonymous saying on a sign in front of the church: “The atheist cannot find God for the same reason a thief cannot find a policeman.”
Atkinson said he hoped the sign would be especially thought-provoking during the Christmas season. “As a pastor, you’re supposed to think about all people, including those who don’t believe in God or are running away from him. I would imagine the holidays are very challenging for them.”
Schleifer, who grew up in a Jewish home and got married in a Presbyterian church, is avoiding the memories and magnetism of both Christmas and Hanukkah. The retired owner of a Miami camera shop grew up in a Jewish household and attended synagogue regularly.
At age 26, he married for the first time — to a Presbyterian — and became active in her denomination. He even taught Sunday school for about a decade. “I became a deacon and an elder. It’s a strange thing. You want to believe, and after a while you get caught up in it,” Schleifer said.
But he stopped going to church and believing altogether in his mid-40s. His first wife, whom he was still in love with, divorced him largely over his refusal to continue participating in organized religion. “I said, ‘Listen, I’d be a hypocrite to go. I don’t believe it anymore.’ I tried to talk to her, but she wouldn’t talk.”
Today, he somewhat grudgingly send gifts each December to his three grandsons in Oklahoma. He feels pressured to buy for them. “This is the big problem with Christmas: People expect gifts,” Schleifer said, “It’s not from the heart.”
He makes another concession to the season: phoning or writing to old friends. “There are people who are special to you. It’s the time of year when it’s conducive to contacting them,” Schleifer said. His approach is, “I want you to know I’m thinking of you, but not in a spiritual sense.”
And Schleifer views much of the hustle and bustle surrounding Christmas as more commercial than spiritual anyway. “The true Christmas spirit is destroyed by all this emphasis on buying gifts. I think if Christ actually did come back to Earth and looked around, he would shudder at what’s being done in his name.”
Yet atheists such as Boyd do find a certain solace in the secular entertainment of the season. For example, Boyd enjoys watching old movies such as “It’s a Wonderful Life” and “Miracle on 34th Street.” He said, “I enjoy them because I see a lot of good happening within the framework of the movie.”
He still enjoys hearing from friends who send Christmas cards. Most know him well enough not to send greetings with religious themes, although he still receives the occasional depiction of wise men following a star. But he doesn’t interpret those as deliberate attempts to convince him that Christmas is holy.
So do they offend him? Boyd answered by invoking a realm in which he professes disbelief: “Oh heavens no.”
Rob, this article is a start. It at least keeps the theists from forgetting that Atheists exist this time of year, but can we please stop this caricature of Atheists being grumpy octogenarians who became Atheists more as a “fuck you” to God and not as a rational dismissal of the concept? Can you not try to find at least one Atheist who makes the cause look good?
And stop interviewing lunatic pastors about Atheists. Moron Atkinson is a bigoted douche nozzle of the highest caliber. He uses his church’s spacious front lawn as a vehicle for political signs, which is illegal. (Remember the “Yes on Marriage” posters? The yellow ones the size of a minivan?) I’ve attended several services at that church and the man is a starry-eyed lunatic whose utopian view is one where Jesus lives in the Oval Office and the rest of the world is either paved over or flies the American flag. These dick sores wouldn’t know an Atheist if one played the organ in their church every week (and I know more than one of them). You don’t have an Atheist’s opinion in every (or any) article about church shit, so why do you need a pastor’s opinion in your article about Atheism?
It’s a step in the right direction, but you have a long, long way to go.
Maybe I’m being too hard on you because you’re local and I try my damnedest to make Roanoke look decent on the Internet, but if I was an editor, I wouldn’t consider this for print. A report on a large group of people cannot be done right when you only report on the two oldest members.