So if you haven’t heard…the site of the former World Trade Center which was going to be called The Freedom Tower has been re-named. The future building and the site where it is presently being very slowly constructed will now be officially referred to by its address, One World Trade Center. Some people are…well…pissed.
I, personally, could care less.
What does the name really change about the building? Or about 9/11? What do people think the name “Freedom Tower” accomplishes that “One World Trade Center” doesn’t? Do we really think that the name “Freedom Tower” is some kind of giant middle finger to terrorism?
Retaining the name of the original building and address is much more powerful than trying to rename the site in a way that trys to be strong and proud, and ends up coming off a bit pathetic.
The issue of the name is really the least of the World Trade Centers many controversies. There have been issues with the building and architecture itself, the memorial, and most interestingly the cultural centers meant to take up residency there.
There were several cultural institutions that were going to be in or around the new building as a part of the new center. They included a performing arts center, a drawing center, a dance repertory theatre, and the International Freedom Center which was specifically designed for the site.
At least two of these have come under fire and will likely be kicked out of their residency opportunities for wanting to display art that is considered “unpatriotic” and “un-American”. While I am ignorant about the exact artwork that inspired the debate, one critic said the exhibit in question was “silly, self-important, half-baked pieces of ‘political art’”. Those on the side of giving the Drawing Center the boot wanted guarntees that the center would never display anything anit-American or that questions the values of New York or freedom.
What is that exactly? How does one define what is offensive or unethical??
And in what context is it appropriate to create art in the wake of a major disaster or catstrophe?
Another group exhibition in 2005 came under fire for being open on September 11, just 8 blocks away from the WTC.
One has to ask…when can we move on??
When are we allowed to stop being silent and to begin creating art, and begin to question what happened and why? Part of processing pain and bearing witness to the traumatic events is to find a voice with which to tell the story of that pain. Part of that is by telling the story…and one of the best ways for people to do that is with art.
How long will we be asked to sit in silence and not process our pain because some people who want to wallow in misery or denial deem the art of catastrophe to be inappropriate?
So do I care about the renaming of the Freedom Tower? Not really. It seems like an opportunity to stop wallowing and to finally move on. There are still hurdles, but this could be a very good step.
–Katie