This is the second post refuting the book Extreme Answers to Life’s Tough Questions published by Family Christian Press, written by Jonathan Gray, Rhonda O’Brien and Shawn A. Harrison.
The book offers nothing but extreme (some would say extremist), simplistic answers to complex problems and leaves no room for questioning. I’m offering these refutations for any teenagers who have had this book inflicted upon them as a guide to questioning rigid church doctrines. The full list of refutations of Extreme Answers can be found here.
This section is all about Absolutes and why they make Baby Jesus wet himself with glee.
Please not that where I use the word Christians, I’m speaking about the majority of mainstream Christians and mainstream Catholics. My grievances against Christian abuse of scripture do not apply to all Christians, but to the Christians that the majority has allowed the become the public face of Christianity.
Christians love absolute authority and strict non-interpretable laws. A quick glance through the history of Christian theocracy will show this with incredible clarity. When Christians have an ethical dilemma and they can point to a page of the Bible and state that a verse clearly and without possibility of interpretation shows what they–and everyone else–should do, they’re at their most dangerous. Remember, it was the single verse, “Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live. Exodus 22:18, KJV,” that caused more torture, death and violence than any other human work in history.
Biblical absolutes would be fine and dandy if just the Christians followed them. If the Christians opened their Bibles one day and saw, “Doth not even nature itself teach you, that, if a man have long hair, it is a shame unto him? 1 Corinthians 11:14, KJV,” and realised that after all these years, they had the dress code wrong, that would be fine. The big preacher-haired preachers would stop fighting to have the biggest hair and start coming up with new ways to trim their head stubble to less than .001 mm in length. All churches would open in-house barber shops advertising only the most fashionable styles of bald. Maybe even the President and the members of Congress would show a little scalp in solidarity with their Christian brothers. And all of this would be fine.
However, Christians can’t simply say, “Well, my Bible tells me to live this way, but you folks have fun with whatever it is that you do.” They have to push it on other people as well. To continue the example from the last paragraphs, if Christians, for whatever reason, started clinging to that verse as vehemently as they do others (Leviticus 18:22, 20:13 and Romans 1:26-27 come to mind for some reason), soon we would start to see old men handing out scissors on the sidewalks outside of the schools. Some students would start leaving trumped-up pamphlets and tracts around school about the medical dangers of long hair. Some parents would force their children into the barber’s chair every Sunday morning and force them to cut off all their hair. Maybe a handful of teachers across the nation would get in the newspapers over having shorn his male students in the middle of a history lesson. Non-Christians with long hair would be scorned in public and would be pressured into cutting their hair so they wouldn’t lose their friends or their family or their job.
So what does the book say about absolutes?
(more…)